Colombia’s second largest city Medellin was safer in the year that late drug lord Pablo Escobar was killed than it was in 2019, according to local crime statistics.
In fact, Medellin’s crime rates were considerably higher in 2019 than they were in 1993, when the city’s most famous resident in history was killed.
Medellin’s homicide rates have gone down since then, obviously, but what does that mean?
The fact that you are reading this article means that you have never been the victim of a homicide, but says nothing about whether you have been the victim of violent crime.
Whether Medellin — or any city for that matter — is safe depends on a lot more than just homicide statistics.
Medellin’s “transformation”
More than 5,000 people, including Escobar, were murdered in Medellin in 1993, which put the homicide rate of the city that had a little more than 1.6 million inhabitants at the time at a staggering 309 murder victims per 100,000 people.
At the time, the chances of getting killed were almost as high as getting robbed as local police received 5,584 robbery reports, according to municipal statistics.
New York City, which had approximately 7.5 million inhabitants in 1993, registered 86,001 robberies and 1,960 homicides that year.
Blue Ocean Strategy (2018)
Fast forward to today, Colombia’s war crimes tribunal in investigating Medellin’s mayors from between 2002 and 2012 for the mass cover up homicides as part of a disinformation campaign to attract foreign investment.
Medellin could be Latin America’s largest mass grave, Colombia’s war crimes tribunal finds out
The collapse of public security
Medellin’s number of inhabitants grew 44% to 2.3 million between 1993 and 2019 when the medical examiner’s office registered 592 homicides that year, a fraction of those registered in the year Escobar was killed.
Mayor Daniel Quintero was hesitant to celebrate, however, amid concerns over forced disappearances that had helped previous mayors manipulate security statistics for years.
Furthermore, the city’s police department in 2019 received 25,313 robbery reports, 450% more than in 1993.
New York City authorities reported 13,363 robberies and 318 homicides in 2019 as the American city reduced its robbery rate by more than 73% and its homicide rate by almost 84% since 1993.
The chance of getting robbed in New York City was almost three times higher than in Medellin in 1993, but seven times lower in 2019, according to official statistics.
Public security in Medellin did not gradually deteriorate to its 2019 low, but has been extremely volatile.
In 2011, for example, local police registered no more than 1,900 robberies.
Whether these numbers are reliable, however, is uncertain as they fall within the period investigated by the Special Jurisdiction for Peace because local authorities were cooking the books.
The same can be said about the 1993 statistics as much of the city was controlled by neighborhood militias at the time.