Colombia Reports

Colombia news, sports, culture and travel

Tuesday
Mar 16th
Text size
  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Home Perspective Sebastian Castaneda Colombia needs more than war policies

Colombia needs more than war policies



"Let him who desires peace prepare for war." Vegetius

Vegetius’ maxim is the Colombian government’s favourite for generations as well as other armed groups seeking to impose their ideals. However, after four decades of this tragicomedy, the government ought to deemphasise war policies and instead formulate a solid peace road map that addresses the social structural problems. Peace achieved through more war would not be long-lasting.

The recent announcement of a USD 4 billion spending on military equipment for the Colombian army illustrates the government’s war policies. The profitable Colombian military industry obtained, in 2006, the exclusive rights to manufacture the current generation of Israeli Galil assault rifles, producing 45,000 annually. Currently, the government is negotiating with Israel to manufacture the next generation of rifles. Moreover, just after the latest hostage release the government has insisted on military rescue for the remaining hostages, when is well-known the FARC would kill all hostages in case of rescue attempts. This was the case with a former governor and later eleven regional legislators, the latter were killed when the FARC mistook an approaching guerrilla group for the army.

The recently released former governor, Alan Jara, echoed the increasing public sentiment that the two main protagonist of Colombia’s conflict benefit from a perpetual state of war. On the one hand, The FARC, as one commander explicated to Jara, long a continuation of the current government war policies because greater war would lead to a “revolutionary situation”, as Lenin envisaged. For instance, the government’s the-means-justify-the-ends actions such as the ‘false positives’ are revitalizing the guerrillas struggle. This marginal support together with the FARC's economic resources would suffice to lure young and poor peasants to their ranks.

In contrast, the war dynamic enables the government to cling to power with a mandate to remove the guerrillas, while advancing economic policies that strengthen the elite. Despite some questionable government’s actions, there is a sizeable number of Colombians assessing Uribe’s government by the success against the FARC. It is true that the government has succeeded in decreasing the FARC manoeuvrability but this has reached an impasse, this is after all guerrilla warfare, a 40-year long guerrilla war. However, policies other than an all-out war are not in the political and economic interest of those elites supporting the current government.

Every time the FARC commences a hostage release the government becomes concern that the all-out war discourse would lose support and a peaceful approach would take hold. This is evident during the recent hostages release when Uribe dismissed left-wing senator Piedad Cordoba, who had helped broker the release, from taking part in Jara’s liberation – Cordoba was reinstated hours later. Uribe implied that the senator had been using this opportunity for gaining political limelight. This is not the first time Uribe has obstructed FARC’s release of hostages. Uribe actions are understandable since a left-wing presidential candidate received 22 per cent of the votes in the 2006 elections. There is no one using the current situation for political gains more than Uribe himself.

The government, instead of following Vegetius’ maxim that only aggravates the conflict, should turn to Sun Tzu’s “The Art of War”. This Chinese ancient text formulates: “when you surround an army, let an outlet free”. This outlet, in terms of the Colombian realities, should start with a humanitarian agreement and continue with a realistic peace process where the social problems afflicting the country are addressed. Therefore, the FARC, at perceiving their futile war are likely to take advantage of this fair outlet, instead of keeping an unproductive stalemate. However, given the government’s intransigency and war interest, Colombians would be wise to support a radically different leader in 2010.

Author Sebastian Castaneda is Colombian studies psychology and political economy at the University of Hong Kong




Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Free and Open Source Software News Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! TwitThis Joomla Free PHP

Comments (10)add comment

NotAlvaroUribe said:

NotAlvaroUribe
...
Wow, one of the best reports I've read.
Highly recommend reading this.
 
February 06, 2009
Votes: -1

Elizabeth Berry said:

0
...
Once again Sebastian Castaneda publishes a brilliant article concerning critical issues, not only for Colombia, but for the world.

If more and more people like Sebastian continue to speak up, we will win. War is no solution for anything and it never has been. In my own country, the Civil War, our worst war ever for our nation where 650,000 soldiers lost their lives [more than in any war since, including Vietnam]--this war was completely preventable. Many economists have done the calculations and if we had simply purchased the slaves and then freed them, the result would have even dollar-wise been a saving--not to mention the lives lost.

To stop war, we need to think differently and more creatively about other solutions. For example, on my website, one of the solutions I offer for Afghanistan is for various governments of the world, including the USA to buy the poppy crop and then figure out a way to put that purchase to use for the good.
 
February 07, 2009 | url
Votes: +0

gringo michae said:

0
...
Sorry I don't find this opinion piece a great piece like the first two posters above, it is like all other opinion pieces written by Sebastian Castaneda, it is more personal attacks of President Uribe then of any substances, If he had left out the personal attacks, and instead wrote in more detail of things the government could be doing to bring peace to Colombia, than it might have been a great opinion piece
 
February 07, 2009
Votes: +0

NotAlvaroUribe said:

NotAlvaroUribe
...
I'll elaborate on my first comment.
It was a great opinion piece because it brings to light the steps that the Colombian government is taking to obtain "security" with their war policies, while it's damaging "peace" efforts. I would recommend this read because there are very few articles that makes a concise report on how the government should go a different path than the one they are taking. This requires criticism toward Uribe and the government, not to be confused as "personal attacks" no matter how much one would admire him. To give details of things the government could be doing would stray from the purpose of this article.
An enlightening article indeed.
 
February 08, 2009
Votes: +0

gringo michae said:

0
...
How does stating details what the Government should /could be doing to bring peace straying what this article is about? The article is saying Colombia is approaching the process wrong, but offers no real concrete tideas that they should be doing instead,. The writer of this article has written many opinion pieces here and in every one has show his great dislike for President Uribe, and has used personal attacks sorry but those are the facts. While I am not a fan of President Uribe, a great opinion piece doesn't use such attacks ,but spells out what is going wrong and what should be done instead, this article fails to do so just like the other artices by this writer.
 
February 08, 2009
Votes: +0

gringo michae said:

0
...
I happen to agree with the writer Colombia needs to adjust the way it deals with the FARC , that a continued war process will not bring this to an end. The time for both sides sitting down to talks has come, With Uribe not seeking a 3rd term, he has nothing to lose by doing so. The fact is ,it is because of his actions the Government can sit down from a position of strength not weakness in talks with the FARC, but Farc has to be willing to give up the demand that the Government clears a wide zone . The talks should be without preconditions with both side working to find a way to finally end this, then maybe finally the people the FARC claim to be fighting for will have peace. There are those who say Uribe doesn't want peace, I beg to differ, for He undertsands that with peace come a huge windfall of pesos to spend on better things then war.
 
February 08, 2009
Votes: +0

iceburner said:

0
...
"Men do not differ much about what things they will call evils; they differ enormously about what evils they will call excusable."

"There is a case for telling the truth; there is a case for avoiding the scandal; but there is no possible defense for the man who tells the scandal, but does not tell the truth."

"Latter-day skepticism is fond of calling itself progressive; but skepticism is really reactionary. Skepticism goes back; it attempts to unsettle what has already been settled. Instead of trying to break up new fields with its plough, it simply tries to break up the plough."

"Most modern freedom is at root fear. It is not so much that we are too bold to endure rules; it is rather that we are too timid to endure responsibilities."

"In the struggle for existence, it is only on those who hang on for ten minutes after all is hopeless, that hope begins to dawn."

Where is GK Chesterton today? NOT in Hong Kong.
 
February 10, 2009 | url
Votes: +0

Pablo Toro said:

0
...
I believe, the war should continue at least until the FARC are more debilitated. History has taught us that FARC will take any kind of peace process to strengthen their military machine.
For those who don't know or remember , towns used to be attacked and destroyed, mass kidnappings used to be practiced by this FARC terrorist while they were following a "Peace Process".
Colombia made the decision to elect president Uribe not once, but twice after he offered to gain back the monopoly of the State and to make sure there were police and military forces protecting citizens all over the territory. So, four more years of military pressure against FARC is definitely the option to follow because what was accomplished during past governments does not have a point of comparison to what this administration has done.
Both FARC and ELN will be debilitated until they have to follow a process like the paramilitaries did where they will not get a millimeter close to obtain a political seat.
 
February 13, 2009
Votes: +0

Pablo Toro said:

0
...
I believe, the war should continue at least until the FARC are more debilitated. History has taught us that FARC will take any kind of peace process to strengthen their military machine.
For those who don't know or remember , towns used to be attacked and destroyed, mass kidnappings used to be practiced by this FARC terrorist while they were following a "Peace Process".
Colombia made the decision to elect president Uribe not once, but twice after he offered to gain back the monopoly of the State and to make sure there were police and military forces protecting citizens all over the territory. So, four more years of military pressure against FARC is definitely the option to follow because what was accomplished during past governments does not have a point of comparison to what this administration has done.
Both FARC and ELN will be debilitated until they have to follow a process like the paramilitaries did where they will not get a millimeter close to obtain a political seat.
 
February 13, 2009
Votes: +0

NotAlvaroUribe said:

NotAlvaroUribe
...
"History has taught us that FARC will take any kind of peace process to strengthen their military machine."

The Colombian government had also used the peace process to strengthen their own military machine. History has also taught us that continuing with war against the FARC will just keep on going and will not end. I see no military end to this Colombian conflict.
 
February 15, 2009
Votes: +0

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
 

Your opinion please

Colombia's best news source is
 

CR members

Advertise with us

Reach out to the tens of thousands reading Colombia Reports